All ArticlesEmergency & General

What to Do If Your Key Breaks Off in the Lock in Arlington

Updated September 23, 2026 4 min read

Key Broke Off in the Lock? Don't Panic — But Don't Make It Worse

A key breaking off in a lock is a common problem, especially with older or worn keys. The good news is that a professional locksmith can extract the broken piece and make a new key — usually without damaging the lock. But what you do in the first few minutes matters. Here's what to do (and not do) if your key breaks in a lock in Arlington.

What NOT to Do

Don't Push the Broken Piece Deeper

If you can see the broken piece sticking out of the keyhole, don't push it in. The further it goes into the lock, the harder it is to extract. Leave it exactly where it is.

Don't Use Superglue

A common internet "hack" is to put superglue on a toothpick or the broken key handle, stick it to the broken piece, and pull it out. This almost never works and it makes the problem worse — glue gets inside the lock and contaminates the pins, requiring a full lock replacement instead of a simple extraction.

Don't Use a Paperclip or Needle

Trying to dig the broken piece out with a paperclip, needle, or toothpick usually pushes it deeper and can damage the lock pins.

Don't Try to Turn the Lock

If the key broke while turning, the lock cylinder may be in a partially turned position. Don't try to force it back — this can jam the broken piece more tightly.

Don't Use the Spare Key

If the lock has a broken piece inside, inserting another key won't work and may push the broken piece further in. Get the broken piece extracted first.

What to Do

Step 1: Assess the Situation

  • Is the broken piece visible? If part of the key is sticking out of the keyhole, extraction is easier.
  • Is the broken piece inside the lock? If it's flush or inside, extraction is harder but still doable.
  • Is the lock a door lock, car ignition, or padlock? Different locks require different extraction methods.

Step 2: If the Broken Piece Is Sticking Out

If you can see and grab the broken piece:

  1. Use needle-nose pliers to gently grip the visible part
  2. Pull straight out — don't twist or wiggle, just pull
  3. If it doesn't come out easily, don't force it — call a locksmith

Step 3: If the Broken Piece Is Inside the Lock

If the broken piece is flush with or inside the keyhole:

  1. Don't try to dig it out yourself — you'll push it deeper
  2. Call a locksmith — we have specialized broken key extraction tools

Step 4: Call a Locksmith

A professional locksmith has specialized tools for broken key extraction:

  • Broken key extractors — thin, barbed tools that slide alongside the broken piece and hook it
  • Keyway picks — tools that reach into the keyway to grab the broken piece
  • Tweezers — long, fine tweezers for reaching into the lock

In most cases, a locksmith can extract a broken key in 5–15 minutes without damaging the lock.

Step 5: Get a Replacement Key

Once the broken piece is extracted, you need a replacement key. If you have the other half (or a spare), we can cut a new key from it. If not, we can cut from the key code or VIN.

See our broken car key replacement guide for car key specifics.

Why Keys Break

Understanding why keys break can help you prevent it:

1. Worn Keys

Keys get thinner and weaker with years of use. A key that's been used daily for 10+ years is much more likely to break. If your key looks thin, bent, or worn, replace it before it breaks.

2. Heavy Keychains

A heavy keychain puts stress on the key where it enters the lock. Over time, this fatigues the metal until it snaps. Keep your car key on a separate, lightweight ring.

3. Cold Weather

Metal becomes more brittle in cold temperatures. A key that's borderline worn can snap during a cold snap. See our winter lock problems guide.

4. Forcing a Stiff Lock

If a lock is stiff and you force the key, the key can snap. If your lock is hard to turn, get it repaired — don't force it. See our jammed door lock guide.

5. Wrong Key in the Lock

Forcing a key that doesn't quite fit can bend and break it. Always make sure you're using the right key.

How to Prevent Broken Keys

  • Replace worn keys — if your key looks thin, bent, or old, get a new one before it breaks
  • Lighten your keychain — car key only, or car key + one or two lightweight keys
  • Fix stiff locks — don't force a key in a stiff lock; get the lock repaired
  • Get a spare key — so you're not using a worn key as your only key
  • Use the right key — double-check before forcing

How Much Does Broken Key Extraction Cost?

Broken key extraction is typically a straightforward job for a professional. The cost depends on the type of lock and how deep the broken piece is. Call (682) 666-2966 for a firm, upfront quote.

Call DFW Key Master

If your key has broken off in a lock in Arlington or anywhere in DFW, call (682) 666-2966. We extract broken keys without damaging the lock and can cut a replacement key on the spot — 24/7. See also our jammed door lock guide and our broken car key guide.

Need a Locksmith Right Now?

DFW Key Master is available 24/7 throughout Dallas-Fort Worth. Call for a firm, upfront quote.